Car Less Ohio

Promoting the bicycling lifestyle in The Buckeye State

Panniers and bivvies and Crocs, oh my!

I’ve been helping my friend Keven select bike-camping gear lately, and so we planned a Sub 24-Hour Overnight to test it out. Keven rode down to meet me in Peninsula, and we left as soon as I got off work at 4:00pm. We headed up to Hudson and stopped at the Acme for supplies.

I brought my commuter bike this time around, because it was the bike most ready to go in touring mode (my Salsa Fargo currently has mountain bike tires on it). Keven rode his Cannondale flat-bar commuter bike, with his gear all on the rear rack.

I had a couple new pieces of gear of my own to test out.

First were my new panniers from Hyalite Equipment (formerly known as Pacific Outdoor Equipment). The rear panniers are sold as a set, and the front panniers are sold individually. The rear panniers are left- and right-specific, with cutouts for heel clearance. The front panniers are ambidextrous. The rear model has zippered side pockets. They all are waterproof, and use a roll-top closure, with side-lock buckles and straps to hold the roll-top in place. There’s a loop of velcro attached to the ends of each strap, so you can roll up the excess strap and hold it in place without it blowing in the wind and getting caught in your spokes. The R&K hardware is adjustable, so you can make it fit almost any rack. It all looks kind of complicated at first, but once you get the hang of it, it’s easy to make all the necessary adjustments the first time you pack up for a trip, and everything just attaches, detaches, opens, and closes easily during your trip. There’s a double pocket on the inside of each pannier, which would probably be big enough for a pair of flip-flops, but not big enough for a standard pair of shoes (or Crocs).

My previous panniers were Axiom Monsoon (front) and Typhoon (rear) panniers. They also had roll-top closures, but with an added flap that dropped down over the roll-top. I found that the flap just got in the way more than anything else when I was trying to get stuff into and out of the panniers, so I don’t miss the flap on the Hyalite panniers.

The one thing the Axiom panniers had that the Hyalite ones don’t is a stiff bottom that allowed the bags to stand up on their own when not on the bike. This was handy when packing the bags at home. I find, however, that during a trip, I usually leave the panniers on the bike most of the time, anyway, so I don’t think I’ll miss this feature, either.

With all of the experimenting I’ve been doing this year with ultra-light, ultra-compact bike-packing gear, the space provided by a full set of four panniers was like being back in the land of luxury. There was a time when I could barely fit everything I needed for a bike trip inside four panniers, but now as I packed for this trip, I kept thinking, “What am I going to put in all of this space?”

In my left rear pannier, I had my sleeping bag, pad, and shelter, with room to spare. In my right rear pannier, I put a pair of Crocs, a pair of pants, t-shirt, sweatshirt, underwear, and a spare pair of socks, hat, pack towel, a bottle of camp soap and sponge, and my toiletries kit; again, all with room to spare.

In my right front pannier, I put my stove, cooking pot, coffee press, bowl, mug, utensils, small pack towel, small scrubbing pad, and fire starter sticks and matches. After putting my food supply in here after the stop at Acme, I still had room to spare.

Finally, the left front pannier was left only for the obligatory 6-pack. While packing, at the last minute I decided to toss in the couple of zip-lock bags full of tools and spare parts. I didn’t think I’d need any of this for a one-night trip, but then figured that since I had the room, it would be foolish not to pack them in case I did end up needing them. This still left plenty of room for the 6-pack as well as room to spare.

The next new piece of gear is not really bike-related, but it’s my new choice of off-the-bike footwear. No matter how comfortable my bike shoes are, I always find that it feels good to have a non-cleated pair of shoes to wear around camp in the evening. I’ve always felt flip-flops were not quite substantial enough. I never thought I’d buy a pair of Crocs; I always thought they were the ugliest and dumbest-looking things around. In talking it out with my other bike-touring friends, though, we came to the conclusion that they’d make the perfect bike-touring shoes. Enough support to walk around for reasonable distances, toe protection, they can double as shower shoes in less-than-ideal facilities, and you can strap them on a rack outside your bags if needed and not have to worry about them getting wet. I decided that if I were going to dive into the world of Crocs-wearers, I may as well dive in feet first and do it right, so I got the garishly bright blue version, to match all of the blue components on my Salsa Fargo.

Finally, the last new piece of gear was the Outdoor Research Highland Bivy. I had been thinking about investing in some kind of ultra-light shelter in place of a full tent in order to get the bulk of my bike-packing gear down even further. The Highland weighs next to nothing, and packs down to next to nothing:

The head area is supported by a single shock-corded pole. It’s got two stake loops on each end, plus a tie-out loop at the top of the hooped head area. I didn’t use any of these, but the stake loops would come in handy if it’s really windy and you need to worry about the thing blowing away when you’re not in it.

The inside is plenty roomy enough for my rectangular inflatable sleeping pad. The head end has a mesh zip-up panel, and then the outer zip-around panel. Getting into the shelter is a bit more of a challenge than a regular tent, but it’s not that bad once you get used to it. It’s not big enough inside to change clothes, but the head area does provide enough space to read or write for a bit before you go to sleep.

I had read in an online review that it’s recommended to leave the outer zip open six to eight inches in order to allow enough air to get inside for you to breathe. I did this after working my way inside for the first time. As I laid there trying to get to sleep, I was panting heavily and out of breath. I figured at first that this was just from exerting myself to get in, so I gave it a few minutes. After about 10 minutes, I was still panting heavily, and I realized that I was suffocating myself. I opened up the outer zipper completely, and that made all the difference in the world; I was able to breathe easy immediately.

With the outer cover zipped almost all the way, the tension from the front and back is enough to keep the hoop upright. However, with the outer cover unzipped, the hoop drooped over. I’ll have to experiment some more; maybe unzipping the cover halfway would provide a balance of enough air with enough support for the hoop. Tying a guy-line to the loop on the top of the hoop would provide good support, but that might make getting into and out of the bivy that much more of a challenge.

There were a few brief showers throughout the evening, but I stayed completely dry. With the outer cover unzipped, I had to try to make sure the edges of the top still hung out over the bottom edge, so that any water falling down would roll onto the ground rather than inside the bivy. This seemed to work well enough during the light rain this evening, but for a full-on downpour, this may not work as well.

In conclusion, the Outdoor Research Highland Bivy provides a reliable and comfortable enough shelter for when I want an ultra-light and ultra-compact option for a one- or two-day trip. Whether or not I could stand having it be my only home for an extended six- or eight-week trip remains to be seen.

Keven and I slept in and took our time packing up our gear in the morning. After making some camp coffee and having some breakfast snacks, we left around 10:30am and rode into Kent for a full breakfast at the Wild Goats Cafe.

2 responses to “Panniers and bivvies and Crocs, oh my!

  1. Keven Fazio October 29, 2012 at 10:50 pm

    Ya, I learned quite a bit on this trip. Unlike my 11 GOBA’s where trucks transport your gear, hauling your own gear adds a new dimension to bike touring. Here’s my take on my first self-supported overnighter.

    I brought my 2008 Cannondale Street, which is a flatbar roadbike with a 50mm headshok, perfect for absorbing bumps in the road. The flatbar provides good lateral stability and the disc brakes work well when wet. An unrelated feature is the ability to swap the 700cx25 wheels for some 26×2.2 knobbies for riding off road. As for cargo, I strapped my sleeping bag to my rear rack and loaded both rear panniers with my tent, cooking gear, clothes, toiletries, tools and two MRE’s. A bento box held my wallet and phone. The weight wasn’t too bad on flats or descents, but did present a challenge on long climbs near the end of a day’s ride. Not insurmountable climbs, but my mind dwelled on new cargo strategies with every foot I ascended.

    After searching high and low for a compact tent, I scored a Mountain Smith 3S, 2 person tent for $100 from eBay. Packs down to about 7”x16” and has some nice features like dual exits, pop-up vents and even Set-Up instructions printed on the stuff sack. Then came time to find a sleeping bag. I like the freedom of rectangular bags, but also wanted one that was rated to freezing without a liner and packs small enough to carry on a bike. I bought a North Face Dolomite 3S, which packs to about 10”x 18” and weighs 4lb.1oz. A little on the heavy side, but worth it for those features. Kevin turned me on to the Klymit Static V sleeping pad, which packs to the size of a soda can and in 15 puffs, lifts your sleeping bag up to 2.5” off the ground. The whole setup was incredibly comfortable – good ventilation in the tent, lots of room in the bag, and stayed toasty the whole night, which dipped to about 50F. Actually wished it would have dropped to about 35F, so I could really test this setup.

    A bit about lighting: I use an Eagle-Tac tactical light, which uses 2xAA batteries and runs up to 89 minutes at 200 lumens or longer at reduced output. I prefer Sanyo Eneloop rechargeable batteries, as they tend to hold a charge longer than most similar batteries. The Eagle-Tac makes a perfect every day light, and easily mounts to handlebars with a Twofish mount. In addition, Niteize makes an adjustable headband, which contains a sleeve for mounting a flashlight. This lets you re-create your favorite scene as Picard-the-Borg, so you’ll want to be careful you don’t accidentally look directly at someone and fry their retina. Also, pack extra batteries where you can find them in the dark (ex.: bento box) or you’ll be using your smartphone as a flashlight to find them sitting at the bottom of a pannier, like I did.

    Kevin suggested a front rack to balance the load. I’ll probably give this a try, plus ditch a couple things to trim some weight, like my Cree Lantern, Pepper Spray, one of the rear panniers and the bag of ice which kept my beverages cold. And by beverages, I mean beer. And unless heavy rains are forecasted, I’ll leave the rain gear at home and bring my PI knickers and Specialized convertible jacket instead. All in all, it was a fun ride and I’m looking forward to the next adventure.

  2. Bike Hermit September 17, 2014 at 7:59 pm

    Thanks for your thoughts on the bivy. I am a Hennessy Hammock guy but, I have often wondered about those. I have used the hammock as a bivy on many occasions though so maybe it’s the best of both worlds.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: